Red Plenty Review Part 2

http://www.tor.com/blogs/2012/08/the-glorious-terrible-strange-ussr-francis-spuffords-red-plenty

Recently I reviewed the novel Red Plenty by Francis Spufford (which can be read here: https://jhame085.wordpress.com/2013/08/23/red-plenty-by-francis-spufford/) I figured it would be fun to read another review of the book (in this case from the blog on Tor.com) to see what another reader enjoyed or didn’t enjoy about it.

If you read the review you’ll find that the blog’s author, Jo Walton, seems to enjoy the book. Like me he mentions how he enjoys the mixture of historical fiction with historical facts to weave a very interesting and telling series of tales. Mr. Meier seems to go a step further into his back research of Francis Spufford research for the book than I did. He mentions in his article that some of the things that the charterers say in the book are, in fact, taken from direct quotes from real people living in the Soviet Union. Walton makes special note of many scenes from the book quoting them word for word.

Walton is also amazed at the level of research Spufford acheived in his research of the book. He mentions the 53 pages of end notes that are included at the end of Red Plenty. Despite the fact that I knew that there were so many end notes in the story it is only after reading this article that I can genuinely appreciate the hard work put into this book. To be honest I feel that this ignorance is quite common among avid readers like myself. We are often so ignorant at the level of hard work our favorite authors put into writing their books.

Advertisements

Jerusalem: Chronicles from the Holy City by Guy Delisle

Credit to Amazon.com

Credit to Amazon.com

There is no more contentious city on the planet than that of Jerusalem in Israel. It is the center of three large scale religions, is claimed as the capital by two countries, and is always in the headlines. With all the controversy and violence that always puts the city in the headlines it is hard to actually view the human aspect of living in the Holy City. Jerusalem gives an interesting look into normal life in the city. This graphic novel tells the story of Guy Delisle’s one year stay in Jerusalem. He is there with his wife who works for Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders) and while she is out working at various hospitals around Israel and Palestine, Mr. Delisle stays in Jerusalem taking care of his children and exploring the city.

Guy Delisle is one of my favorite authors/graphic artists, as his travelogues (which Jerusalem is the most recent) are not only beautifully written and drawn, but also give an amazing insight into the lives of people in foreign countries that people in the West don’t get a chance to experience very often.

The graphic novel is broken into twelve chapters which are based on the month of the year that the events take place. Each chapter has more than a few short stories which are all only two or three pages long at most. Each story tells of a specific interesting instance that Mr. Delisle experiences in his daily life. One interesting story tells how on Yom Kippur all major streets a temporarily blocked off. This is because Yom Kippur (a major Jewish Holiday) is the Sabbaths of Sabbaths and as well all know Sabbaths in all Abrahamic Religions are days of rest. In Israel on this day rest is more or less forced on all, hahaha.

Another more serious story tells about the Israeli Remembrance Day or Yom Hazikaron. This is a state holiday that is Israel’s equivalent of America’s Memorial day. However, this memorial day is expanded to include the victims of the Holocaust as well as and Jews who died in the foundation of Israel as a country since 1860. The main even of the day on this holiday is the moment of silence. During this moment of silence sirens are heard throughout the country and everyone, no matter what they’re doing stop stand up and stand silently for a minute. Everyone is involved in this. Cars on major highways stop and their passengers get out to observe it. A video of this can be seen here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=80de02Skgdk . In Delisle’s story he witnesses the moment of silence as all those around him stand as the sirens blare. All those, except for tourists he talk loudly and don’t even seem to notice what’s going on.

As well as focusing on Israeli’s Delisle also focuses on the Palestinians who live and work in Jerusalem. Most of these instances are also quite sad as in many of the stories which include Palestinians they are more or less treated as second class citizens. For example Delisle and his family live in a Palestinian district in Jerusalem. Despite the people in the district paying trash pick up taxes to the city, their trash is never picked up and their living standards are noticeably lower than their Jewish Counterparts. I eagerly suggest this book as well as any of Guy Delisle’s other works for anyone who is interested in places that are generally ignored by the mainstream. I suggest this book in particular for anyone who needs a good introduction to the problems of Israel and her sister Palestine.